No child left behind, Teacher's Unions, Voucher programs, Charter Schools, teacher accountability, blah blah blah....
It's a popular debate for sure. Everybody has an opinion on "what is wrong with our education system..." Probably just as many people that have opinions on "what is wrong with kids today..."
When I hear folks in the media debating these problems - I'm struck that there is an understood assumption that there is a problem or that there has been a decline and people never discuss or debate what specific problems they've observed. Sure, you hear the occasional stat stating that we rank X in the world in X - but seldom do the solutions to these barely investigated stats have anything to do with solving those issues directly.
I don't know anybody with school aged children that would say their kids aren't learning anything or that they were more advanced than their children. But most of them still accept blindly that we have a problem.
The problems being debated seem more like solutions in search of a problem.
No Child Left Behind (aka Standardized Testing) - No evidence that this has done anything to enhance learning. If anything all these programs and laws have done is inflate expenses of education on the tax payer due to the large Standardized Test industry without any measurable improvements in learning.
Teacher's Unions and Teacher Accountability - My wife was a Teacher in Public schools for years. She was an outstanding teacher - and she had many tales of teachers that did the bare minimums to get by. Of course, I've been in the military, I'd worked for municipal government and I've been in the private sector for many years and my observations about my peers are pretty much the same. A small number of star performers, a lot of average ones and a few that are worthless. There may be a few organizations built of solely elite performers - but none that are as large as a typical school district. It's the job of Principals to manage the performance of their employees just as I do in the private sector. Few, if any, other professions are as unfairly scrutinized by people that know nothing about the professionals then that of the Teaching profession. Teachers are an easy scapegoat and politicians know how to take advantage of that. Go after teachers and it looks like you are going after the "problem". Truth be told - in life you have great, average and poor peers, co-workers, bosses, competition, etc. etc. I learned from my great teachers just as I did my poor teachers. Teaching children to blame their teachers for their inability to learn (rather than taking extra effort on their own) does not prepare them for college or the real world and it teaches them a victim mentality. Let the principals deal with low performers - get the politicians out of the classroom.
Voucher Programs and Charter Schools. Charter schools are fine. No problem with communities experimenting with education, but the push towards "Voucher programs" is nothing more than a way for politicians to pander to a group of parents that actually do care about their children's education that think that putting their child in a different school will make all the difference. There is no evidence that voucher programs have helped students be more successful than they would have been. It's a cop out. It's "doing something" but again, does nothing to improve education for the kids who's parents won't take advantage of the vouchers and ignores the unintended consequence of the impact to the more popular schools if a large percentage of parents did.
Ok, so here is my take on the "Education Problem".
Much of it is nothing more than political nonsense. It's a topic that most reasonable people feel passionate about, but don't understand. Throw in a few Chicken Little soundbites about the failing state of Education, create some scapegoats to go after and it's an easy formula for winning votes.
The problems that do exist (and have always existed) have more to do with socioeconomic and cultural factors than it does with "Teachers" or "Tests".
I have two older brothers. The three of us were all high school drop outs. One of my brothers has seven kids. None of them graduated high school. My cousins have 100% graduation rates, all in college and all with children that finished school.
What was the difference?
For me, it was socioeconomic. I was raised by a single mother. My education wasn't a focus. When my grades slipped as a teenager, I wasn't punished and guided, it was ignored. When I turned 16, I got a job and worked every night until 1am. Because I couldn't relate well to kids that had stable families, my best friends were from broken homes with little parental involvement like me.
I was a smart kid. Always did well in class - but I had a problem doing homework. I had a bigger problem going to class. I failed the majority of my classes my Junior year. I fell into the same trap as my older brothers and there was noone there to set me straight.
I did eventually set myself straight. I got my GED, joined the military and used the GI Bill to fund my education. I did well in college and I've done well in my professional career. I took responsibility for myself and used the four years in the Navy to get my act together and change direction.
However, I am the exception, not the rule. I see my nephews and nieces who were raised with no parental involvement in their education. Zero for Seven on High School graduation and they aren't genetically inferior - they were just raised in a broken home by two parents that were dropouts. They had to deal with the stress of poverty. They fell into groups, that had similar backgrounds as them and fell into different vices (drug use, etc).
Sure, some schools can be better than others. Some teachers can be better than others - but the problems with our children's education start at home. Plain and simple. The majority of dropouts live in poverty. If you eliminate the impoverished from our academic performance, the United States jumps to number 1 in the world. Anyone that cites low graduation rates or our low standing in the world on academic performance that doesn't discuss the impact of home-life and socioeconomic factors is using the disadvantaged for political gain.
Folks, it's time that we stopped allowing politicians to play games with our education system. They aren't fixing anything, if anything they are making things worse.
Sunday, September 23, 2012
Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Fun Day with the Dogs
Decided to take the dogs to a Frisbee competition today. Goofball is quite the Disc Dog, so I thought I'd see how he did.
Well, he did fantastic. Not sure what the scores were - but out of 26 teams, he came in second!! Actually tied for 2nd after the finals and had to do a tie-breaker round. He killed it. Great dog.
Well, he did fantastic. Not sure what the scores were - but out of 26 teams, he came in second!! Actually tied for 2nd after the finals and had to do a tie-breaker round. He killed it. Great dog.
![]() |
| Me welcoming Goofball with open arms after he wowed the crowd. Love my dog! |
Sunday, March 25, 2012
Intro to my Blog
Welcome to my blog.
My name is Doc Cheriway. I'm currently researching issues in Organizational Culture and Trust. Two things that I believe can be determining factors on the success or failure of an organization.
While I'm in the initial phases of my research, like anyone that has been in the workforce for 25 years, I've experienced how differences in Organizational Culture can impact member Trust and overall performance in the organization.
My hope is to have interesting and insightful conversations about factors impacting organization's performance and hopefully learn some things as I work on finding new and innovative ways to develop healthy cultures and success in organizations.
I hope that others' with a passion for this topic will feel free to join in this topic with me!
Thanks
My name is Doc Cheriway. I'm currently researching issues in Organizational Culture and Trust. Two things that I believe can be determining factors on the success or failure of an organization.
While I'm in the initial phases of my research, like anyone that has been in the workforce for 25 years, I've experienced how differences in Organizational Culture can impact member Trust and overall performance in the organization.
My hope is to have interesting and insightful conversations about factors impacting organization's performance and hopefully learn some things as I work on finding new and innovative ways to develop healthy cultures and success in organizations.
I hope that others' with a passion for this topic will feel free to join in this topic with me!
Thanks
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

